logo

Contact Us

  • Utica First Insurance Company
    5981 Airport Road
    Oriskany, NY 13424
  • 800-456-4556
  • Direct: 315-736-8211
  • General Fax: 315-768-4408
  • Accounting Fax: 315-736-1836
  • Claims Fax: 315-736-2139

For Billing/By Mail

  • Utica First Insurance Company
    PO Box 851
    Utica, NY 13503-0851

If you are an individual or business and are interested in more information regarding our policy offerings, we would be happy to assist you in locating independent agencies in your area that write Utica First Insurance policies. Please email us at marketing@uticafirst.com.

Please be advised that the Utica First Insurance Company is licensed to write business ONLY in the states of Connecticut, New Jersey, New York, Massachusetts, Maryland, Ohio, Virginia, Florida.


Directions

From North (Watertown):

  • Take Route 81 South to Exit 25A - NYS Thruway I-90.
  • Take NYS Thruway (I-90) East to Exit 32 - Westmoreland.
  • After leaving the thruway tollbooth, turn LEFT on to Cider Street.
  • Drive for about 3 miles until you come to Judd Road.
  • Turn LEFT on to Judd Road and go about 1 mile to Airport Road.
  • Turn LEFT on to Airport Road.
  • Utica First is the second building on the RIGHT on Airport Road.

From South (Binghamton):

  • Take Route 12 North and go Northeast for about 64 miles to Route 315 (Buell Ave) in the town of Waterville.
  • Turn LEFT onto Route 315 and go Northwest for about 5 miles to Route 12B in the town of Deansboro.
  • Turn RIGHT onto Route 12B and go North for 3 miles to Route 233.
  • Turn LEFT onto Route 233 and go North for about 7 miles to Cider Street in the town of Westmoreland.
  • Turn RIGHT on to Cider Street and go about 3 miles to Judd Road.
  • Turn LEFT on to Judd Road and go about 1 mile to Airport Road.
  • Turn LEFT on to Airport Road.
  • Utica First is the second building on the RIGHT on Airport Road.

From East (Albany):

  • Take NYS Thruway (I-90) West to Exit 32 - Westmoreland.
  • After leaving the thruway tollbooth, turn LEFT on to Cider Street.
  • Drive for about 3 miles until you come to Judd Road.
  • Turn LEFT on to Judd Road and go about 1 mile to Airport Road.
  • Turn LEFT on to Airport Road.
  • Utica First is the second building on the RIGHT on Airport Road.

From West (Syracuse):

  • Take NYS Thruway (I-90) East to Exit 32 - Westmoreland.
  • After leaving the thruway tollbooth, turn LEFT on to Cider Street.
  • Drive for about 3 miles until you come to Judd Road.
  • Turn LEFT on to Judd Road and go about 1 mile to Airport Road.
  • Turn LEFT on to Airport Road.
  • Utica First is the second building on the RIGHT on Airport Road.