Utica First Insurance Company  |  Email Us  |  800-456-4556

Leadership and Directors

Utica First Insurance Company

Utica First icon

Leadership

Scott A. Shatraw

Scott A. Shatraw
President &
CEO

Richard R. Shlotzhauer

Richard R. Shlotzhauer
Senior Vice President &
Director of IT

Shawn Kain

Shawn Kain
Vice President &
Chief Underwriting Officer

David Jarvis

David Jarvis
Vice President of Agencies

Scott Richards

Scott Richards
Vice President of Marketing

Susan Wheaton

Susan Wheaton
Vice President of Claims

Kyle Burch

Kyle Burch
Controller

Melissa Mann

Melissa Mann
Director of Underwriting

Ryan Goux

Ryan Goux
Manager of Underwriting

Debra W. Crane

Debra W. Crane
Accounting Manager

Pauline Cieslak

Pauline Cieslak
Building Manager

Nicole Manley

Nicole Manley
Human Resources Manager

Dennis Williams

Dennis Williams
Claims Manager

Directors

  • Alan R. Leist, Chairman of the Board
  • Greg Evans
  • L. Michael Fitzgerald
  • Richard R. Griffith
  • Kirk B. Hinman
  • Camille T. Kahler
  • Eve Van de Wal
  • John A. Zawadzki
  • Richard J. Zick

Emeritus

  • Dominick D. Carbone
  • J. Kemper Matt
  • John B. Millet, Jr.
  • Earle C. Reed


Find An Agent By:

or

States we serve: CT, FL, MA, MD, NJ, NY, OH, PA, VA


My Policy

Unique, cost effective commercial insurance products for small and medium sized businesses.

Learn More

View more


Payment Options

Unique, cost effective commercial insurance products for small and medium sized businesses.

Learn More

View more