Find An Agent Agents Brokers My Policy Payment Options Pay My Bill Find An Agent
Home About Leadership & Directors

Leadership and Directors

Utica First Insurance Company

Utica First icon
Bio background texture

Scott A. Shatraw

President & CEO

Bio background texture

Shawn Kain

Senior Vice President &
Chief Underwriting Officer

Bio background texture

David Jarvis

Senior Vice President of Marketing and Agencies

Bio background texture

John Burns

Vice President of
Information Technology

Bio background texture

Michael Siedlecki

Vice President of Claims

Bio background texture

Kyle Burch

Vice President of Finance

Bio background texture

Ryan Goux

Director of Underwriting

Bio background texture

Debra W. Crane

Accounting Manager

Bio background texture

Pauline Cieslak

Director of Customer Experience

Bio background texture

Nicole Manley

Human Resources Manager

Bio background texture

Dennis Williams

Director of Claims

Directors

  • L. Michael Fitzgerald,
    Chairman of the Board
  • James McCarthy
  • Greg Evans
  • Kirk B. Hinman
  • Camille T. Kahler
  • Eve Van de Wal
  • John A. Zawadzki
  • Lous B. Tehan
  • Dr. Randall VanWagoner

Emeritus

  • Dominick D. Carbone
  • J. Kemper Matt
  • John B. Millet, Jr.
  • Earle C. Reed


Find An Agent By:

or

Distance: within 15 miles

States we serve: CT, FL, MA, MD, NJ, NY, OH, PA, VA


My Policy

Unique, cost effective commercial insurance products for small and medium sized businesses.

View Policy

View more


Payment Options

Unique, cost effective commercial insurance products for small and medium sized businesses.

View Options

View more
Contact
UsCall
800-456-4556