Marketing Reps

If you are an independent insurance agent, writing business in Connecticut, Florida, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Virginia, and would like more information about Utica First Insurance Company, please contact one of our Marketing Representatives below.

Leadership Team

David Jarvis, CIC
Senior Vice President of Marketing and Agencies
800-456-4556 Ext. 3004
djarvis@uticafirst.com

Upstate New York

Stuart Blodgett
Marketing Representative
315-580-0140 (cell)
800-456-4556 Ext. 3301 (voicemail)
sblodgett@uticafirst.com

New York Downstate

Keith M. Arnold
Marketing Representative
516-477-6583 (cell)
800-456-4556 Ext. 3306 (voicemail)
karnold@uticafirst.com

Pennsylvania, Maryland

Keith Dawson
Marketing Representative
570-971-3714 (cell)
800-456-4556 Ext. 3303 (voicemail)
kdawson@uticafirst.com

New Jersey

Michael Cerchio
Marketing Representative
315-580-9803 (cell)
800-456-4556 Ext. 3308 (voicemail)
mcerchio@uticafirst.com

Massachusetts, Connecticut

Connie Bedaw
Marketing Representative
603-732-2637(cell)
800-456-4556 Ext. 3304 (voicemail)
cbedaw@uticafirst@uticafirst.com

Virginia, Florida

Kenneth Sommer
Marketing Representative
315-570-1001 (cell)
800-456-4556 Ext. 3309 (voicemail)
ksommer@uticafirst.com

Ohio

Catherine Casterline
Marketing Representative
614-582-1716 (cell)
800-456-4556 Ext. 3307 (voicemail)
ccasterline@uticafirst.com

Upstate New York

Cora Fargo
Marketing Coordinator
800-456-4556 Ext. 3007
cfargo@uticafirst.com

Marketing Reps

Leadership Team

Upstate New York

New York Downstate

Pennsylvania, Maryland

New Jersey

Massachusetts, Connecticut

Virginia, Florida

Ohio

Upstate New York

Find An Agent By:

States we serve: CT, FL, MA, MD, NJ, NY, OH, PA, VA

My Policy

Payment Options